From teenage dream to ‘Marty Supreme’

From teenage dream to ‘Marty Supreme’

Chalamet starred in “Little Women” in 2019.
Courtesy | Pinterest

“It’s no use, Jo.”

Any Gen-Z woman can quote the rest of the dialogue between Laurie (Timothée Chalamet) and Jo (Saoirse Ronan) from Greta Gerwig’s 2019 “Little Women.”

A young and zealous Chalamet delivers a fervent performance as Laurie, embodying the loverboy persona of his early career. This beloved Chalamet is a far cry from what the audiences see in his recent projects. But, Chalamet’s range across his career demonstrates he is still honing his craft, the mark of a great actor.

Anyone watching Chalamet as Laurie would find it difficult to believe the same actor would later play Bob Dylan, feature on a British Scouse rapper’s song, and cause a ruckus online with his acceptance speech at the 2024 Screen Actors Guild Awards. Based on his demeanor early in his career, his fans might have expected a modest thanks when he took home best Male Actor in a Leading Role for “A Complete Unknown.” Instead, Chalamet delivered a monologue that shocked both Hollywood and his fans.

“I know the classiest thing would be to downplay the effort that went into this role,” Chalamet said. “I know we’re in a subjective business, but the truth is, I’m really in pursuit of greatness. I know people don’t usually talk like that but I want to be one of the greats,” Chalamet said, raising his award. “This doesn’t signify that, but it’s just more fuel, a little more ammo to keep going.”

Some regard Chalamet’s dramatic shift away from tear-filled eyes and floppy hair as a rejection of so many years of films in which he played roles within a designated stereotype. Many remain entirely agnostic about whether he has the range and raw talent required for true acting “greatness” like Daniel-Day Louis or Denzel Washington.

Chalamet has been open about fresh ambition and direction. “The Bob Dylan metaphor is ‘going electric,’” he said in a 2023 interview with Vogue magazine, referring to the moment at the Newport Folk Festival in 1965, in which Dylan shocked his loyal fans with rock and roll. He used the quote to say experimentation and expansion in the name of art is worthwhile, even if it’s shocking. Chalamet may sound arrogant, comparing his own early career to Dylan’s acoustic career. Yet his analysis was pertinent at the time and can act as a beacon of hope for Hollywood, even if this Chalamet sounds very different from the actor’s sensitive artistic beginnings.

Chalamet first made a name for himself in “Lady Bird” (2017), “Call Me By Your Name” (2017), “Beautiful Boy” (2018), and “Little Women.” In all of these performances, his emotional range only goes from playful youth to depressive. While he played these characters well, it is understandable that such monotony could be stifling for an actor. While many noted a definitive change in his demeanour around his SAG acceptance speech, the transition began well before that.

His career and film choices over the past couple years were intentional and strategic, beginning with his role as Willy Wonka in 2023’s “Wonka,” a deliberate echo back to his musical theatre years in high school and his broadway debut as Jim Quinn in “Prodigal Son” (2016).

When Chalamet followed his whimsical role as Willy Wonka with his starring role in “Dune,” many fans of the books were skeptical that this wiry, adolescent-looking man could personify Paul Atredes. Yet Chalamet stunned audiences with a commanding and domineering screen presence in both Dune films. After this, he began work on his role as Dylan, proving he could use his musical talent, lean more into method acting, and take on the identity of an American icon.

All of these choices climaxed in his SAG acceptance speech.

Chalamet starred in “Marty Supreme” last December.
Courtesy | Pinterest

Straying further from audience expectations, Chalamet emerged with a strong social media presence in December 2025 to promote his new A24 film, “Marty Supreme,” in which he plays a star ping pong player. If one only watched the trailer for “Marty Supreme,” the role appears analogous to Chalamet’s so-called arrogance. But Chalamet portrays a character who strives for “greatness,” exploring a cautionary tale of the American dream and the importance of integrity and morals, undoubtedly a pertinent allegory regarding his stage in his acting career. Marty must come face to face with fame and becomes morally defunct because of it.

The public’s response to Chalamet in the last year is puzzling. Articles from The Free Press and British GQ praised his expansion, while hardcore fans on TikTok mourned his artistic and “indie prince” era, as The Guardian called it. While it’s still to be determined if he has the talent to be the Daniel Day Lewis of our time, his pursuit of acting greatness and his focus on craft is conservatism and classicism at its finest. In the narcissistic and mediocre air of the celebrity world, Chalamet offers a fresh, classic talent to modern cinema.

Loading