The anomalous frequency of conversions to Catholicism at Hillsdale College is certainly newsworthy. And despite the traces of condescension and triumphalism that inevitably attend such accounts, the Collegian’s Jan. 16 article, “Core and conversation inspire Catholic conversion at Hillsdale,” did nicely illuminate the manner in which many understand their conversions. Given its emphasis on the important role conversation often plays in such journeys, however, it is unfortunate that there was no acknowledgement of the conversations that quite regularly do not take place. Namely, those one might expect potential converts to have early and often both with their parents and with those clergy already entrusted with their spiritual care.
“Passionate and respectful theological conversation” with Hillsdale’s “community of devoted Catholics” is all well and good — if one is not at the same time intentionally avoiding similar conversation with the equally devoted of one’s own communion. Far too often, students whose interest in another theological tradition has been piqued simply (and silently) begin absenting themselves from worship and study at their own congregation, begin avoiding certain topics with certain professors, and, most curiously, neglect to mention any of this even to their parents until formal conversion is imminent.
Even those not inclined to cynicism might wonder whether such behavior betrays pangs of conscience or a less than courageous desire to avoid challenging questions. Given the well-deserved reputation of Hillsdale’s students, one would hope that intellectual honesty and filial piety alike encouraged them to solicit and to welcome feedback — and pushback — throughout the process of any contemplated conversion.
Korey Maas is an associate professor of history at Hillsdale College.
